Random Discourse – The Yaw Shin Leong “Affair”

Finally, the suspense is over. The Workers’s Party [WP] has expelled Yaw Shin Leong from the party. A by-election in Hougang will most likely be announced once the budget debate is over.

I clearly cannot imagine how much more damage there would be to the party’s image and prestige had the matter dragged on. A number of friends I talked to were originally rather disappointed with the WP for not coming clean on this matter. Some have even lost faith in the WP as a political alternative. All that about a ‘First World Parliament’ would be empty talk if the WP intend to kept mum about the matter and hope that the electorate would forget about it in 2016. While those were in the opinion that the WP would need time to investigate the matter or allow Mr Yaw to explain himself, the complete silence on the matter prior to the high profile expulsion was rather disappointing and disheartening. Hopefully the WP can learn from this lesson and handle negative matters better in the future.

It was clear from Mr Low’s strong reaction (when he was told what the Prime Minister had said) that he did not want to let down the people of Hougang. I respect him and the WP in making this most painful decision. Hougang has been in the care of the WP for 2 decades and the WP has decided to stand before the people and asked them to be the judge. There is nothing more transparent and democratic than that. I applaud the WP for its courage in doing the right thing – excise the tumor before it becomes a cancer. It is my opinion that courage is apparently something that the People’s Action Party [PAP] lacks. Otherwise we wouldn’t have to wait until last May for some ministers to step down, when they clearly should have been removed from their posts way before.

Now, on the matter of Yaw Shin Leong’s alleged affair. From what I know this originated from nothing more than an article from a garbage site (one which I shall not offer more publicity by naming) which has a history of being anti-WP. I am surprised that the main stream media [MSM] picked up such rumors and actually published it. For a very brief moment, I actually thought they have finally obtain some proof but it was sadly short on details. While it is most unlikely that the MSM would be able to get anything more out of that garbage site, the MSM kept up the pressure on Mr Yaw and WP relentlessly, especially on the evening Chinese tabloids which my parents read daily. Meanwhile, this very same media had reported that PAP MP Foo Mee Har has publicly called certain attacks on her to be false and baseless. But what attacks is she talking about? The same media which pressed Mr Yaw to address those allegations with dogged determination leaves many of us with our heads in the fog regarding Ms Foo. Such double standards… so much for professionalism!

As to whether Mr Yaw’s private life has anything to do with his ability to serve, I find it hypocritical that many would come to the defense of celebrities who misbehaved but hold politicians to a different standard. For e.g. Few would give a damn if Britney Spears drove with her baby on her lap without a seat belt, or that Amy Winehouse died because drug overdose. When people claim that political leaders are role models, let’s be frank with ourselves and ask who has a greater impact in the daily life of teenagers. Clearly, more would be listening to the songs of their idols instead of a speech from our uninspiring political leaders.

So, I personally don’t really care about Mr Yaw’s private life since as far as politics is concerned I would value capabilities above morality. After all, I am in the opinion that the standard of ‘whiter than white’ is one that is incepted into the our collective social psyche by the PAP to the point that we Singaporeans come to believe that this has always been something we wanted. As far as I can remember, that seem to be something more often used by the ruling party to justify itself. While it is a standard we aspire for our politicians and civil servants, Yaw isn’t the only one who has failed in that aspect recently. Yet, I also have to agree with those who believed otherwise that having an affair is simply the betrayal of one’s spouse – the very person one has taken a vow to love, protect and respect forever for the rest of his / her life. It is the worst betrayal one can commit to a loved one. Many would find it it difficult to trust such a person, much less believe that he would be able to serve them faithfully and truthfully.

That brings me to the end of my post. Allegedly, Mr Yaw and his wife and the lady he has an affair with, all seek counseling on the matter from their church leaders. Assuming that this is true, it means the “information leak” is from the church. I am clearly under the impression that church counselors are expected to keep such matters confidential because their members seek help from them in good faith. While there is Biblical basis to expose and discipline an unrepentant member, it does not include revealing it anyone and everyone outside the church. While the garbage site had actually accused the church of helping to cover this matter up, it is common sense that this attempt has failed. Someone who is personally involved in counseling or close to the counselors has bragged it out. I could not think of any other plausible leak if not from within the church itself. If it was a careless slip of tongue by someone close to the counselors (or even the counselors themselves) and done without malice, then it is a simple matter. It would however be more ominous if someone has deliberately exposed Mr Yaw because of their political differences in spite of their faith in God.

Anyway, this matter has finally come to an end. I wish the WP good luck and hope that it retains its seat in Hougang. I forgot to mention… for those who wants to ride on the WP’s misery as a short cut into Parliament, I hope you lose your deposits if this turns into a multi-corner fight.

Workers’ Party Hougang Rally – April 28, 2011

I must say I am shocked by the crowd at the Workers’ Party [WP] rally in Hougang. The field is just a few minutes short walk from Hougang MRT Station along the North East line, and even before I reach the actual position, the few of us – including my friend’s old mother who came without any free food – had a hard time getting into rally ground proper.

At the rally site, we joked that many of the people at the rally are just kaypohs (aka nosy parkers) since among the 7 of us, 4 came from areas where the Workers’ Party do not directly contest. I didn’t stay for the whole rally because I don’t want to leave when everyone is leaving as I have no faith in the ability of the MRT system to be able to take the load, neither do I want to let a taxi driver earn some easy money by calling for a cab.

I arrived late at around 7:40pm and left at 9:30 so I only heard a few people speak. Loud cheers went up when Mr Low Thia Khiang arrived, and more cheers went up when he introduce his protégé – Mr Yaw Shin Leong. My friend tried to cheer for Mr Yaw but he couldn’t get it going and I understood his intention since while Mr Low deserved our cheers, we can’t only cheer for him forever. That is perhaps something the Workers’ Party should work on.

Anyway, I managed to hear Miss Lee Lilian, Mr Yaw and Mr Chen Show Mao speak. Mr Chen spoke in several language, even greeted those present in Malay and Tamil. If I had any doubts that this is a son of Singapore, my doubts went out of the window. The crowd itself and my camera was quite a distraction so I didn’t remember everything that the candidates said.

One thing I did catch however, was Mr Yaw (I think it was him) imploring those who came from other constituencies where the WP is contesting to vote for the WP. He mentioned that it is rather disheartening to see a large turnout at the rallies many times, but the votes always came out otherwise. I sincerely hope that this won’t happen this time round since the stakes are so high. Even so, I am heartened by my fellow Singaporean’s increased political awareness. My concern is that the turnout at Hougang today may cause some voters to be taken in by the PAP’s scare mongering (i.e. of a so-called ‘freak result’) and vote for the PAP instead on May 7th. That would have created another kind of ‘freak result’, one in which the PAP gets a clean sweep in spite of its past few years of mismanagement in certain areas. So vote wisely, Singapore. Vote boldly. As Chen Show Mao says: Don’t be a cowardly lion!

The pictures I took at the rally doesn’t do the crowd present any justice. I should have taken a picture of the crowd standing behind me when I was leaving. Do note that that area behind me was empty when I arrived. By the time I was leaving I could see nothing else except people. It was an amazing night and I sincerely hope that our democracy is finally taking root and sprouting flowers of spring.

By the way, I got myself a blue Workers’ Party umbrella as a souvenir. Yaaaay!

To laugh or to cry? (I)

I was just scrolling through Workers’ Party @ Parliament blog when I read the following exchange between opposition MP Low Thia Khiang and one of the so called ‘elite talents’ (精英人才) of the Tali-PAP on 28 Feb 2008:

Mr Low Thia Khiang (Hougang SMC): First clarification, the member in his speech said why should we quarrel with the discrepancy in the estimates because we are in a happy situation where we have a huge surplus instead of a deficit.

Does he agree that he misses the point? The point is not so much whether we end up with a huge deficit or huge surplus, the question is: why is the Budget estimate so far off the mark?

Second clarification: He says that if our estimate is off the mark, Hong Kong is even worse than us because they are off the mark much more than Singapore’s estimates.

I’m afraid that if this is the attitude of the People’s Action Party, we are going down a slippery slope. We are not so good in estimates, he says, but never mind, there are people who are worse than us.

So in Mandarin, this is exactly what we call ‘Ah Q jing shen’ (mentality)*.

Dr Lim Wee Kiak (Sembawang GRC): In fact when I did my block visit last night, a resident asked me the same question: why does the Government have such a huge surplus? Did something go wrong in the estimate?

Looking at the papers this morning, when Hong Kong reported a huge surplus – four times above the estimate – the main reason given was it was an unprecedented year, property prices went up, they had huge transactions in the stock market. A similar phenomenon was seen in Singapore as well.

I told the resident: At the end of the day, I think the key question for this House is how do we look forward?

When the family breadwinner came back and said: ‘I’ve struck lottery”, you shouldn’t be asking, ‘Why did you strike lottery?’

You should be asking: how are we going to use the lottery money? So I think we should not miss the point. The real issue now is: What can we do now to make sure that there will be less and less need for all these social welfare programmes in the future. Look forward and not backward.

* Ah Q is a famous character in Chinese literature, known for his foolishness and optimism.

I was rolling the floor laughing my ass off when I read Lim’s reply. The fact that this guy actually holds a doctorate, makes it even more hilarious. This is the kind of replies I would have imagined Ah Beng and Ah Seng would have come up with.

Try and imagine this… Citizen Lim Dong Chiang told his wife that getting himself sterilised would have been a good idea because they can just continue to enjoy unprotected sex, save the money use for contraception, and not worry about having a baby.

One year later, Dong Chiang’s wife came home and told him she is pregnant. And when Dong Chiang goes looking for Dr Lim, I can almost imagine him giving this advice: ‘You don’t ask where the baby come from, Chiang. I think we should not miss the point. The real issue now is: What you can do now to make sure you have the money to raise the baby in the future. Look forward not backward.’

You know, if it was an opposition MP who said this he would have definitely have been ridiculed in Parliament, and by Singapore’s lapdog media until he has no place to hide. Remember what happened to Lim How Doong when he said, ” Don’t Talk Cock! ” in Parliament?

This is enough to make one weep but at the meantime, you don’t know whether you should be laughing or not!

Well done, Sembawang GRC. This is one of the clowns you gave 76.7% of the votes to. I suppose the Singapore Zoo probably could teach Ah Meng’s offsprings to be MPs better than they act… and they probably takes normal peanuts – not the TT Durai kind – for pay too.

Sembawang GRC, will you find the courage to fix this problem, the next time round? Or will you continue to keep them and spoilt them?