I was sort of surprised to see on Monday [19 Jan 2009], posts about the Association of Bloggers Singapore (ABS for short) from some of the friends I have been following on my rss reader – namely DK, Eastcoastlife, Endoh, nicole, xinyun, and xtralicious.
I know I am 2 days late in reporting this, but I have my own concerns and misgivings about it originally. All that time I was trying to get through to some of the members in the committee pro tem to answer some of my queries.
Meantime, criticisms came as fast as (if not faster than) the news of its birth and blog articles reporting it. Some of the most common criticisms are: the need for a subscription; the lack of a proper website giving details on what it is about; an attempt to define who can be a blogger and impose guidelines to what can be written; and * gasp * the government’s gahmen’s first step in controlling blogosphere!
Let us look at each of these controversies and analyse them. Are they facts, just allegations or straw man?
- The need for an entrance fee and a subscription
This is a fact and one of my primary concerns. My personal opinion is that ABS should reconsider the position of some student bloggers who can write well. I also reflected to several of their members the importance of proper accounting to the public and members as even non-profit activities like Social Media Breakfast (SMB) came under the scrutiny of a blogger.
From what I gathered, the money collected will be used to cover activities in the event no sponsors are found, and none of it is used as salary or allowances for the committee for their roles. Money that is not spent will most likely be donated to charities. There seems to be some dissenting voices within the committee itself, whereby some have requested that for a trial period the fees should be waived until a year later. If you have any queries here, it is really best to direct it at the committee. - The lack of information on the website
This is a fact. Anyone who has visited the site can see that for himself and I consider it as public relations fiasco until I understand from some of the committee members, ABS has a pre-matured birth.
The official launch will be in late February. DK told me they did not intend to announce the moment it becomes officially registered and had originally intended to announce it’s official launch date maybe later in the week and open to questions from the general public. Unfortunately, the article on TODAY forced their hand, and they have to reveal it before time. They are now working hard to get an FAQ up. - An authority to issue guidelines on writing and to disqualify non-association bloggers
Among one of the most ludicrous speculations. Just how does one expect ABS to enforce their guidelines? By confiscating your member fees? Taking you to court? I brought up the matter of whether ABS intends to negotiate a better deal with advertisers like Advertlets, Nuffnang or Blog2U on behalf of bloggers and I was told that is never an objective of ABS as it cannot enforce anything on its members.
As to the matter of disqualifying non-association of bloggers, Xtralicious has put it across to me: Can the Chinese Association disqualify you from being a Chinese simply because you are not a member? One is a blogger simply by setting up a blog on any of the blogging sites or self host using a blogger software. It will take gahmen legislation to disqualify a person as a blogger and that takes me to the last point. - Gahmen Control
Chairman Pro-tem EastCoastLife seems to me to have many contacts in high places. At least that is the impression I have from this blog also authored by her. In my opinion, this has always been a convenient straw man. I recalled the days I used to post on soc.culture.singapore when people who didn’t like a pro-gahmen post will label its writer a gahmen lackey.
But consider this: If endorsement or having close relationship with gahmen bodies and officials is justified as a step leading to gahmen control, then it is equally convenient for anyone to label collaboration with foreign talents justifiable as being disloyal to, or engaging in subversive and hostile activities against our nation!
Whichever way the allegations go, they all have only these objectives – to inspire fear and to polarise – and then have you decide that the decision they want you to make is the best for yourself. I must point out that one shouldn’t be over-zealous in their nationalistic fervor before it becomes distorted as xenophobia or facism.
The above is my personal opinion on the formation of this association. I am not rallying for anyone to join, but I would plead with everyone to give the founders and committee some time to come up with the official answers.
As bloggers, some of us may not like the personality or the writing style of another person, but let us all refrain from having old skeletons dancing out of the closets and revisit old hatreds. While no one can force you to abide to this and remain civil, it will only make yourself look bad in the eyes of stalkers readers. Don’t forget that we bloggers are not all to blogosphere, our readers whom we somewhat influence with our thoughts makes up the other part. It would do us some good to remember that some of our readers may have even more clarity of thought than some of us do.
Shalom Aleichem. Peace be with you.
Comics:
Recommended Reads:
Singularities Industries: Whose side are you on?
Join MY blogger association on Facebook! No fees, no approval necessary! http://tinyurl.com/fatas
AcidFlask´s last blog post: Now Announcing: the AcidFlask Fan Club
Hey, great article. I wanted to ask a few questions myself, but as I wrote I realised the list got to long to be a comment and decided to not comment afterall. LOL. In the end, some things are best left unsaid, untouched and under-wrapped. Again, great article.
Hey Xizor, while the official FAQ is not up yet… I am glad to let you know there is a special student rate that we have planned right from the start. The spending powers of students (especially during such economic times) were already put in consideration. 🙂 More will be revealed in the upcoming FAQ.
There are plenty of delays in alot of stuffs. The last when we enquired, we were given given strict instructions not to organize any events or make any announcement until ROS gives us the green light. Our hands are pretty much tied. We are not above the law, afterall. 🙂
Ed´s last blog post: Jack Neo says Love Matters
A well written blog post. *claps*
Chaosdingo´s last blog post: Weirdo dream