The following statement was made in this blog post which reported the recent case in where ‘star blogger’ Michelle Quek was allegedly hit on the back with an umbrella by a lady and then punched in the face by the lady’s foreign boyfriend:
“The only reason why I’m posting this video is beacuse she’s a blogger and I think bloggers should stick together.”
Wait a minute! So if she’s not a blogger then it’s alright for us not to stand with her? When did it make a crime more serious than it is simply because the suspect is a foreigner, and the victim is * gasp * a local blogger? Worst yet, should we only be outraged only when a ‘star blogger’ is assaulted? Do I stand back when somebody got punched in the face and kicked on the leg, simply because she’s a nobody? Come on! This doesn’t make any sense at all!!
Anyway, I still gave the incident a closer look. While I did feel some outrage when I heard that a foreigner has attacked a local and her friend, which were both young girls, it appeared to me that this case wasn’t as clear cut as that of Bo Davis and the trishaw uncle.
All we can see in the two video clips, was really just the aftermath, and in my opinion, a display of ‘mob justice’. It was not a video of what happened, and I honestly couldn’t take a stand without hearing the foreigner’s side of the story. In fact, is there anyway to ascertain that we have the full story even when we had listened to both sides? (An excerpt of Michelle’s side of the story can be found here.)
Some might argue that based on the fact that bystanders came to offer assistance to the girls and to detain the foreigner, it would mean the foreigner is definitely at fault. However, can anyone be absolutely certain the bystanders had also witnessed what happened prior to the chase and the foreigner’s violent act? Personally speaking, I suspect that any man who saw his girlfriend getting chased and outnumbered two-to-one would have intervened physically. This is simply what any men worth their salt should do. (But that being said, it does not mean I agree with resorting to violence to achieve that end even though the foreigner might have assumed that his girlfriend was getting bullied.)
So, while I would have normally rant about the foreign talent policy and on how foreigners failed to respect our way of live and our traditions, I find that I couldn’t work myself up to a rage to do it this time. I would normally have condemned any bad-mannered or misbehaving foreigners – be it PRs, new citizens or tourists – but I will refrain from letting my emotions run high in this case.
I would appeal to my fellow bloggers, let’s not use our blogs to influence our readers or to turn it into an avenue of mob justice, in which suspects are condemned without being allowed to adequately defend themselves. Administering justice is the job of the judge and our courts. It would not do well for the reputation of our country if Singaporean bloggers make the world see us as an unreasonable and xenophobic bunch.